Fantasy Football: Start Achane or Williams Week 10?
Week 10 of the fantasy football season is upon us, and you're likely facing some tough decisions. One of the most debated matchups this week involves two rookie running backs, Devon Achane of the Miami Dolphins and Tank Bigsby of the Jacksonville Jaguars. Both players have shown flashes of potential, but who should you start in your Week 10 lineup? Let's break down the factors to consider for each player.
Devon Achane: The Explosive Playmaker
Achane burst onto the scene with a 52-yard touchdown run in Week 7, showcasing his incredible speed and agility. He's a dynamic weapon for the Dolphins offense, but his role within the offense is still evolving. Achane is primarily used on passing downs and as a change-of-pace back behind Raheem Mostert.
Factors Favoring Achane:
- High Ceiling: Achane's explosive playmaking ability makes him a threat to break a big run any time he touches the ball.
- Passing Game Involvement: Achane is a reliable target for quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, which gives him consistent involvement in the offense.
- Potential for Increased Role: As the season progresses, Achane could see an expanded role within the Miami offense.
Factors Against Achane:
- Limited Touches: He's currently competing with Raheem Mostert for carries, limiting his overall volume.
- Matchup Against a Tough Bills Defense: The Bills have one of the best defenses in the league, which could limit Achane's production.
Tank Bigsby: The Powerhouse
Bigsby has shown glimpses of his powerful running style, but his touches have been inconsistent. He's a physical back who can grind out yards between the tackles, but he hasn't received the same volume as other rookie running backs.
Factors Favoring Bigsby:
- Potential for a Workhorse Role: Bigsby could eventually become the lead back in Jacksonville, especially if the Jaguars decide to move on from Travis Etienne Jr.
- Strong Running Game: The Jaguars have a strong offensive line and a commitment to the run, which creates opportunities for Bigsby to gain yards.
- Matchup Against a Vulnerable Colts Defense: The Colts defense has struggled against the run, which could favor Bigsby's production.
Factors Against Bigsby:
- Inconsistent Touch Count: Bigsby's touches fluctuate from week to week, making him a risky fantasy start.
- Competition from Etienne: Etienne is still a major part of the Jaguars' offense, and could limit Bigsby's overall opportunities.
The Verdict: Who to Start
This decision comes down to your risk tolerance and overall fantasy football strategy.
-
If you're looking for upside and potential for a big performance, Achane is the better choice. He has the speed and explosiveness to break a long run, but his limited touches make him a risky start.
-
If you're looking for a more consistent floor and a reliable contributor, Bigsby might be the safer option. He's unlikely to break a big run, but he should see enough touches to provide solid fantasy points.
Ultimately, the best choice for your fantasy lineup depends on your specific team needs and your assessment of the matchup. Good luck with your Week 10 decisions!